Chapter 6 - DADDY SAID YES

Claire held the notebook with both hands.
âTell me this is fake.â
Daniel swallowed.
Margaret answered instead.
âItâs called parenting.â
Claire snapped the notebook shut.
âI asked him.â
Danielâs voice was low.
âI didnât know she was writing everything down.â
âThatâs your defense?â
âNo.â
âYou agreed to this?â
âI agreed Lily needed structure.â
âShe is five years old.â
âShe was throwing tantrums at dinner.â
âBecause she was hungry!â
âThatâs not what Mom said.â
Claire stared.
âSo you believed your mother over your child.â
Danielâs eyes filled with frustration.
âYouâre twisting everything.â
Rachel laughed from the doorway.
âShe doesnât have to twist anything. Your mom kept records.â
Margaret pointed at her.
âYou need to leave.â
Rachel smiled.
âCall the police.â
Nobody moved.
Claire flipped deeper into the notebook.
There were months of entries.
Measurements.
Punishments.
Comments.
Too emotional today.
Sneaked banana.
Asked mother for extra milk. Claire enables overeating.
Claireâs grip tightened.
Then she found a page marked FAMILY PLAN.
Danielâs handwriting appeared below Margaretâs.
Not a signature.
Actual notes.
Stop snacks after preschool.
No second portions unless vegetables finished.
Weekly weigh-in okay.
Claire looked at him.
âYou wrote this.â
Danielâs shoulders dropped.
âYes.â
The single word hurt worse than the slap.
Claire whispered, âWhy?â
âMom said Lily needed boundaries.â
âDid you ever ask Lily?â
âSheâs a child.â
âExactly.â
Daniel stepped closer.
âI thought we were helping her.â
âNo. You thought obeying your mother was easier than being a father.â
His face tightened.
âThatâs not fair.â
Claire shoved the notebook against his chest.
âRead it.â
âIâve seen it.â
âNo. Read it.â
âClaireââ
âREAD IT.â
Daniel looked down.
Claire pointed.
ââCried for twenty-three minutes after being denied breakfast.â Read the next line.â
Daniel remained silent.
Claire read it herself.
ââEventually stopped asking.ââ
The kitchen went quiet.
âYou trained our daughter to stop asking for food.â
Margaret sighed dramatically.
âOh, for Godâs sake.â
Claire whirled around.
âDo not speak.â
Margaret blinked.
Claire had never spoken to her that way.
Not once in nine years.
Claire walked closer.
âYou hit me tonight because I challenged you. What did you do to Lily when she challenged you?â
Margaretâs face hardened.
âI never hit her.â
Lilyâs voice came from behind them.
âYes, you did.â
Everyone turned.
Claireâs heart stopped.
Lily stood in the kitchen entrance.
Rachelâs husband, Mark, was behind her looking apologetic.
âShe woke up crying. She wanted you.â
Claire rushed toward her.
âBaby, you werenât supposed to be here.â
Lily pointed at Margaret.
âShe hit my hand.â
Margaret went pale.
âWhen?â
Lily held up her right hand.
âWhen I took bread.â
Claire crouched.
âDid it leave a mark?â
Lily nodded.
âIn the bathroom.â
âWhat bathroom?â
âGrandma took a picture.â
Margaret moved suddenly.
Toward the counter.
Toward her phone.
Rachel got there first.
She snatched it away.
Margaret shouted, âGive me my phone!â
Rachel backed up.
Claire stared at Margaret.
âWhy did you take a picture?â
Margaret said nothing.
Lily answered.
âShe sent it to Daddy.â
Claire turned toward Daniel.
Danielâs face went white.
May you like
And Claire knew there was more evidence.
Much more.